Cielo – Visit to Heaven
by J.E. Pizarro, Foodies Like Us
One of the fun things about Scottsdale is how over a period of 15 years, the city has grown, changed and otherwise re-invited itself time and time again. A place that I recently went back to is the Hotel Theodore.
From its Holiday Inn incarnation, to The James Hotel, to The Mondrian and now to Hotel Theodore, the location has always been a staple of downtown Scottsdale nightlife.
If you’ve been into any of the incarnations, you know that there has always been a restaurant inside of the property. From Fiamma, to Asia de Cuba and now to Cielo. The latest has a chef from San Diego who recently moved to the valley. His drive and determination to make Cielo a destination is apparent in the way that his menu is designed.
Chef Comer is eager to jump into the culinary scene and attract those of us that enjoy good Italian influenced food and a good ambiance. From his last location at Seasons 142 in San Diego (not to be confused with Seasons 52), his penchant for unique dishes and an unparalleled dining experience remain intact as he undertakes Scottsdale latest restaurant located at the Hotel Theodore.
Now let’s talk about the food. Traditionally when I do a review, I order off the menu, take many pictures and avail myself to the wine list the restaurant has to offer. This time, I let Chef Comer send out individualized dishes so I could taste a variety of items from the menu.
The first course on the docket was a Hand cut Yellowfin Tuna Tartare with a truffled avocado puree can caper berrries that was drizzled in chili oil. I know.. I know.. Everything these days has truffle oil in it, however in this case you couldn’t taste the “rumor” of truffle until the end. Light and refreshing, the nice acid balance and great seasoning make this an excellent dish to start out the evening.
Second up for tasting was the Tomato and Buffalo Mozzarella with basil foam. My dining companion commented that the mozzarella was more like a buratta. Soft, flavorful. I gave it a nice sprinkling of fresh ground pepper. The tomatoes, were juicy, colorful and every bit as tasty as I’ve had.
A third course before we got into the heavier items was the Local Garden Salad with spiced walnuts, baby beets, pickled fennel, gorgonzola cheese with lemon tarragon dressing. You know those salads that you wish you had at work when it comes to lunchtime? This was it. Anyone that knows me knows that I “hearts” me some beets.
The white prawn scampi was next on the list. Let me just say that perfectly cooked shrimp seems harder to come by than you would think. From the celery leafy green to the warm white center of the shrimp, I would order this dish again in a heartbeat.
The Hill Farms Pork Tenderloin with a semolina gnocchi was the highlight of the evening. Perfectly roasted to a medium rare, the marsala reduction was hardly even needed. It was succulent and visually stimulating and would satisfy the hungriest of diners.
If you are thinking about visiting Cielo, they have some very enticing offers during the weekends. Did you know they (the restaurant) does 50% on wines on Fridays and Saturdays? I certainly didn’t! But you can best bet I’ll be taking advantage of that. In addition they also do 2 for 1 drinks on Saturdays.
Check their specials out through their Facebook page as well as their Twitter presence! And now that the weather is cooling down (at least I’m waiting for it), their outdoor patio overlooks the peacefulness of the Scottsdale Civic Plaza. Grab your spouse, friends or your twitter foodie BFF and check out Cielo.
Check out what other things we are doing at Foodies Like Us!



























































